03 January 2018

End Content: Raids vs Dungeons

I've seen this in every single game. I haven't seen any exception anywhere and it seems to be always the same: You level open world, then you start doing dungeons and after you go into raids and that's it.

Small Complaint Incoming

This is something I don't understand. Okay, yes, dungeons are five-man-content. Okay, yes raids are more than five, but why are raids more end-content and dungeons not? Why do raids give better loot than dungeons? Is it because raids are harder? Most often, yes - I guess. Is it because raids require more people? Is it because just hearing the word >>raid<< has something to it? The aesthetics or something?

It Could Be Different

Alright, now that I've got that off my heart. Let's imagine an MMORPG. Alright, you start leveling as usual - okay with me. After some time spent you reach the point where you can do dungeons. So you obviously do some dungeons while leveling at the same time and then you reach the maximum level. You find a group or a guild and you enter dungeons to get "ready" for raids.

A bit of a hassle, but later you're equipped and ready to go - ready for raids. So you start raiding enjoy your first raid. At some point you have content-clear. Luckily the developer brings out a new expansion pack. What does it include? A new dungeon and a new raid.

And here's where things get interesting in my opinion:
With this new content update, we're implementing a new end-game dungeon and end-game raid. You will be able to do this dungeon after completing the first raid, getting your equipment to be able to do the second raid.

Or if we want to go without power creep:
With this new content update, we're implementing a new end-game dungeon and end-game raid. The dungeon will implement the concept of the new mechanics of the raid. So if you want to practice these mechanics or do not find a raid group you can try this challenge instead.

I'd dig that. So let's look at the difference between a raid and a dungeon?

Raid vs Dungeon - What's the difference?

A dungeon is usually a single instance that contains enemies and mini-bosses as well as an end-boss. It is usually a five-man-content but Guild Wars 1 also goes with an eight-man-composition.

A raid, on the other hand, is usually a single instance that contains enemies, mini-bosses, bosses and an end-boss. Usually, you have ten or more people who do this.

So let's ask again...
Raid vs Dungeon - What's the difference?

The number of people and the number of bosses.

Technically we could say raids are bigger dungeons.

Innovation

A dungeon can be more difficult than a raid by adding horizontal difficulty. Make some dungeons that implement different not yet seen mechanics and make the raid implement a handful of these mechanics, but at the same time, combining them.
I think the design idea of having dungeons -> raid -> dungeons -> raids -> dungeons -> raids is much more appealing. Also, dungeons take less time to develop than a raid. Even better having created dungeons and use those boss mechanics as the base for the raid bosses doesn't have you implement completely new mechanics. Just make sure it feels different than the single mechanics of the dungeons, though it's not bad to feel familiar. You could even change the mechanics a little bit to feel similar yet different. (No one likes copy & paste :P)

Dungeons Only Works Too

Guild Wars 1 is a game that did not have any raids. And it didn't need raids. You had always eight-man-groups in end-game areas. Dungeons were already difficult and that's just the start. Aside from normal dungeons, it had hard-mode dungeons and elite dungeons as well as elite instances. People who have experienced the underworld or the domain of anguish know what I talk about. You don't need raids to have end-game content. 

Conclusion

What people want is some kind of progression. Any kind of progression. 
If it's a progression through horizontal learning like in Guild Wars 2 and Guild Wars 1, 
if it's a vertical progression through power creep like in WildStar and World of Warcraft
or if it's a vertical progression through learning (stacked) mechanics. 

If you provide this for different sizes of groups you're good to go.

02 January 2018

Scaling Content: WildStar vs Guild Wars 2

Games that have a gear grind or a power creep, in which you get stronger and stronger, too strong for the previous content have a problem. At some point, your equipment and character are completely overpowered, too overpowered for the current content. So you're too strong for the current content and even stronger than that for the older content. Where's the challenge? That's why game designers and developers came up with a new concept.

Scaling Content

The idea behind this is, that the content scales in difficulty. To name a few games that have implemented this: Diablo III, Guild Wars 2 and WildStar.

Looking at Guild Wars 2 and WildStar we have:

Guild Wars 2 to allows the player to select between 100 different levels with a handful of different scenery in the Fractal of the Mists dungeon. The higher the level the more difficult.

WildStar uses a prime system. With level 50 you can start working on a primal matrix by collecting essences from different types of content. This matrix allows you to be stronger for higher prime content. There's the selection between prime 0 to prime 15, although the maximum item level drops at prime 13. The higher prime levels are just for essences and the kick of difficulty.

So What Changes Between the Levels?

In Guild Wars 2 with each level, the number of standard mobs and their levels increase. Also, these creatures have more health and do more damage. Comparing different difficulty tiers, some enemies also get new abilities. From level 20 on it also implements a new mechanic called agony. This is a damage over time that either comes from the presence of big bosses or from certain attacks of bosses and mini-bosses. Agony deals with a percentage of your health as damage and can be reduced with agony resistance. From level 26 on the fractal levels start to get debuffs from stacking deals damage and agony damage when attacking an enemy to enemies explode after death. At level 71, when a player gets downed a Fractal Avenger will spawn and try to stomp the downed player.

WildStar, on the other hand, decreases the player's damage, while increasing the enemy's damage and health.

Comparison: Guild Wars 2 vs WildStar

As you can see compared to WildStar in Guild Wars 2 a lot more changes between the levels happen. Of course, if the enemies live longer by having the players damage decreased and the monster's health increased the fights take longer. If the fights take longer mechanics play a greater role. Additionally increasing the damage of the monsters requires healers to heal more tanks to be able to work with more incoming damage and it decreases the allowance for errors. Aside from scaling up to dodge-able attacks that kill in two hits, Guild Wars 2 does the same. The health of enemies increases and their damage increases. So here too, enemies live longer requiring players to survive mechanics much longer. Compared to  WildStar, Guild Wars 2 raises the stakes further though. From level 26 on players are limited in their playstyle due to the instabilities. At level 51  it's two instabilities already and with level 76 it's three instabilities.
The following instabilities are currently available:
  • No Pain, No Gain     - Enemies receive protection (33% less incoming damage) might (increased damage) and fury (increased critical hit damage)
  • Last Laugh                - Enemies explode when killed
  • Afflicted                    - Enemies apply random damage over time effects
  • Social Awkwardness - Receive agony and damage from nearby allies when you attack enemies
  • Toxic Trail                 - Enemies leave a trail of toxic sludge behind them as they move around
  • Flux Bomb                 - you are periodically afflicted by a flux bomb. (an AoE that explodes with another AoE lying around afterward
  • Adrenaline Rush        - Enemies become enraged for a time when low on health
  • Hamstrung                 - The lower your health, the slower you move.
  • Fractal vindicators    - The Fractal Avengers are replaced by more powerful foes.
  • Mists convergence     - Different enemies, effects or mini-bosses from other fractals spawn at random 
Additionally, some enemies gain new skills and abilities the higher the levels are and to top this all another death mechanic is added to the stack at level 71.

What Makes This Better?

It's not necessarily the amount of changes Guild Wars 2 implements. Actually, it's just one big thing that can be summarized as: "Feels different". That's all it needs. The higher the difficulty the more difficult it should be, obviously. However, it should also be a different difficult, even just a little. Scaling the same content up higher and higher doesn't change the difficulty much. If you were able to get a gold dungeon in WildStar, running higher levels that equal your groups new equip and damage will still be gold. The only interesting part is the levels higher than your group's equip and damage. Unfortunately scaling enemy damage and lengthening the fights makes them more annoying and boring. It's nothing new, it's the same fight like every other time only difference it goes longer and being unconcentrated or making a mistake is punished more heavily. This doesn't work as good since Guild Wars 2 applies new mechanics, which makes fights more difficult. Enemies attacking faster, more to take care of, more to think about during the fight and new things to learn while increasing the time of the fight just by the amount that is required for it to feel longer but not too long.

So What Should We Take From This?

If you're implementing scaling content make sure that there's a difficulty curve. Additionally adding new mechanics on higher levels even if it's just a small attack or some little thing the players need to do, with increasing levels all this will play together resulting in a difficulty that feels much better. Combine this with increasing health and damage of the enemies and you've got a good scaling system.


Keep in mind though, this is all just my opinion on the topic! So don't take it for granted!

01 January 2018

Guild Wars 2: The Underwater Problem

Underwater worlds and levels. Who doesn't hate them? Super Mario Brothers, Super Mario 64, Banjo Kazooie, Sonic the Hedgehog. If there was a water level it sucked. Though I must say many underwater levels like the ones from Donkey Kong Country, for example, looked and felt beautiful.

So What Made Underwater Levels Suck? 

I don't know if people agree with my opinion here but personally, water levels felt slow and maneuvering felt everything but precise. Having an air system that may run out made it all even worse. I understand that these mechanics are supposed to be like that. Have you ever walked next to someone swimming? Guess what? you're walking faster than they're swimming. Have you noticed that the Zora transformation in The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask lets you swim much faster? Or the frog suit in Super Mario Brothers 3? Have you tried to stay underwater for longer than five minutes? (I hope not...)

From a game design perspective that's fine. Nothing to complain here.

Enough About Other Games

Anyways enough about other games. The problem we want to focus on is the underwater in Guild Wars 2. So what is it that makes the underwater fighting so lame in Guild Wars 2? Well, several aspects.

Areas of Effect

Above ground, underground or wherever but not in the water, you can place AoEs and enemies place AoEs. Aside from all the effects and everything flying around you can see all the damage fields you have to avoid or look at the precaution or warnings shown before some attack comes. How are you supposed to show these underwater? How are you supposed to see the effects of swimming around next to you?

Additionally, placement skills can't be placed in the middle of the water. You can either place them on you or on the enemy. How fair is that depending on the skills?

Abilities Underwater

Compared to on the ground, underwater disables several of your abilities. Okay, it makes sense that a few skills do not match underwater fighting. Can you imagine swimming flower turrets, a drowning flesh golem or something like that? I can't. Unfortunately, some elite specializations like the scourge have all their new learned skills disabled underwater and it gets even worse with

Weapon-Based Traits

"Your scepter now does more condition duration", "Your greatsword heals" etc. etc.

Notice something? Let's check my weapons underwater... hmmm.. none of those. Yeah, this kinda makes the traits completely useless. They have no effect underwater. None at all. So There's no reason to take these traits with you, however, there isn't a better option to compensate for the missing ones. This is a huge problem with dealing damage underwater lowering the damage of players and lower damage means longer fights which then means it gets boring or annoying.

My Suggestions

I already mentioned before I don't like to criticize without giving suggestions and well... sometimes it's hard to find one. In the case of area of effects underwater I'm kinda left in the dark, unfortunately. Of course, you could mark the area with a red bubble or an orange bubble that fills or something. At the same time, this might decrease how well you can see things. You could make it opaque... but I don't know about that. I guess you could try going for opaque.

To the rest of the problems, one solution could be to add elite specializations for underwater fighting. Unfortunately, you would have to change your build every time you go underwater or alternatively add an "underwater" build like the distinction between PvE, PvP and WvWs builds. The other solution could be to change the skills to work underwater. Like the flesh golem of the necromancer becomes a flesh shark - currently thinking about the Pirates of the Caribbean's ghost sharks. The traits could be changed to implement the underwater skills and weapons in them raising underwater damage onto the same level as on the ground.

In The End, It's All Opinions

I think a lot of people agree that underwater fights don't feel "right". The suggestions I posted here depend on my own opinions. Someone else might disagree, but it would be cool if we find a way to agree with something that improves the underwater fighting to feel much better and allow us to enjoy this content of Guild Wars 2 as well.

Besides, I think we all agree that fighting the dragon S... on some planks on the open sea sounds ridiculous.

BONUS CONTENT

Another aspect I didn't wanna mention is underwater PvP. Before the only water map was removed from the rotation and re-implemented without water there was an Elementalist bug that allowed him to infinitely go into downstate mist form when a top of water. Even worse is the aspect that back in those days there was no stomping underwater, which means ranger were nearly invincible in downstate while the pet was reviving.

About Me

My photo
I'm a M.Sc. Games Engineer and I created this blog to share my ideas, theorycrafting, thoughts and whatever I'm working on or doing.